The decision to replace a highly successful Christmas advertising campaign with a new execution raises a strategic question for marketing leaders: when should a brand refresh its advertising, and when should it allow a successful idea to become an enduring brand asset?

Amazon’s latest Christmas advertising campaign has prompted a fresh debate about one of the most persistent challenges in brand management: the pressure to create something new even when an existing campaign is already delivering strong results. In an analysis published by Adweek, marketing commentator Mark Ritson questions the decision by the global e-commerce company to replace its acclaimed 2023 Christmas advertisement, “Joy Ride”, with a new seasonal film titled “Joy Delivered”. The argument goes beyond a disagreement about creative preference. It challenges the tendency of marketing organisations to confuse the need for novelty with the need for effectiveness.
The new advertisement tells the story of Joy, a traveller whose flight home on Christmas Eve is cancelled because of severe weather. Determined to reach her family, she continues her journey by bus, boat and taxi, encountering strangers along the way. She gives some of the Amazon parcels intended for her family to people who help her, turning the story into a narrative about generosity, human connection and the spirit of Christmas. The production uses a new version of the Beatles’ “Golden Slumbers” to reinforce its emotional tone. It is a cinematic advertisement built around the familiar themes of kindness, giving and belonging that seasonal campaigns routinely seek to evoke.
Ritson’s criticism is that Amazon already possessed a highly successful Christmas advertisement in “Joy Ride”, which first appeared in 2023. The earlier film featured three older women watching children sledging on a snowy hill. One of them orders seat cushions from Amazon, and the women subsequently join the children on the hill, briefly rediscovering the joy of their youth. The advertisement relied on visual storytelling, nostalgia and an instrumental version of “In My Life”. According to Ritson, it received the maximum 5.8-star rating from System1, an advertising effectiveness research company. When Amazon brought it back in 2024, it reportedly achieved another exceptionally high score of 5.7 stars.

What Christmas Advertising Teaches Marketers
The significance of the debate lies in the commercial value of consistency. Advertising is often judged internally by how new, visually impressive or creatively ambitious a campaign appears. Consumers, however, do not experience a brand’s advertising in the same way that the marketing team does. A campaign that has been reviewed repeatedly in boardrooms, creative presentations and approval meetings may still be relatively unfamiliar to the audience. What feels repetitive to the advertiser may be only beginning to become recognisable to the consumer.
Ritson cites research from System1 suggesting that advertising does not necessarily lose its effectiveness simply because it has been used before. He also points to Coca-Cola’s long-running “Holidays Are Coming” campaign, which has been part of the company’s Christmas advertising since 1995. The campaign demonstrates how a distinctive seasonal asset can become an important part of a brand’s cultural identity. Its familiarity is not necessarily a weakness; it can be the very reason audiences anticipate its return.
This distinction matters because brands are built through repeated associations. A distinctive visual, sound, character, slogan or narrative can gradually become part of the mental shortcuts consumers use to recognise and remember a company. Consistency helps reinforce those associations. Replacing a familiar campaign too quickly may mean sacrificing accumulated recognition and emotional equity in pursuit of a temporary sense of creative freshness.
The issue is particularly relevant to businesses operating in Nigeria and other African markets, where marketing budgets are frequently constrained and the cost of reaching consumers can be substantial. Companies may spend heavily on television, outdoor advertising, digital media, influencer partnerships and sponsorships, yet change their creative direction before audiences have had enough exposure to remember the message. A new chief executive, marketing director or agency may arrive and immediately seek to distinguish the next campaign from the previous one. The result can be a succession of disconnected executions that generate activity but fail to build a coherent brand identity.
That does not mean brands should never change their advertising. Consumer behaviour, competitive conditions, cultural expectations and product propositions evolve. A campaign can become inappropriate, lose relevance or fail to represent the business’s current strategy. There are also situations in which a new product, market or audience requires a different creative approach. The strategic question is whether the organisation has evidence that a change is necessary, rather than merely a desire to demonstrate creativity.
Amazon’s situation also raises an important management issue: the difference between the perspective of the marketer and that of the customer. Marketing teams live with their campaigns for months. They review scripts, storyboards, production footage, edits and media plans before the public sees the final work. Consumers encounter the advertisement in a different environment, often briefly and among hundreds of competing messages. The organisation’s familiarity with the campaign should not be mistaken for audience fatigue.
Christmas Advertising Lessons for African Brands
For African businesses, this lesson extends beyond Christmas advertising. Banks, telecommunications companies, consumer goods manufacturers, retailers and financial technology firms can benefit from developing a small number of recognisable brand assets and sustaining them over time. A campaign platform should be evaluated not only by its immediate reach or engagement but also by whether it strengthens memory structures, communicates a consistent promise and makes the brand easier to identify.
The decision to retain or replace a campaign should therefore be based on evidence: brand tracking, advertising effectiveness, customer response, distinctive asset recognition and the campaign’s contribution to commercial objectives. Creative renewal should strengthen brand equity rather than reset it unnecessarily.
BrandiQ analysis: Amazon’s Christmas advertising campaign debate illustrates a fundamental principle of strategic brand management: advertising is not simply a sequence of creative releases; it is an investment in memory. Organisations that constantly replace their messages risk making consumers start the recognition process again. In markets where advertising expenditure must work harder, consistency can be a competitive advantage. The best question for a marketing director is not whether the organisation is tired of an advertisement, but whether the audience has finished learning from it.



